As a big jalapeño fan, I plan to head back to Aldi to grab them. I got an 8-ounce bag of Clancy's original kettle chips for about $2. I could see the hype for the Happy Farms string cheese.

Now, over 360,000 loyal shoppers have taken the fan-favorites survey, deeming items like Mama Cozzi's take-and-bake pizza and Happy Farms' string cheese Aldi must-buys. I tried every fan-favorite ...